Casey James American Idol 2010 Top 10 Guys -

AliBailey2010 Says:

Mar 4, 2010 - Casey James did seem a little too "stiff" during this performance however he DID NOT lack the "dirt" and whilst he may not have delivered "perfect" vocals, he definitely delivered!

thecougar2 Says:

Mar 4, 2010 - Casey was neither stiff nor did he have any problems with his vocals performance on that song. Replay the video. The problem here lies that Miss Cougar seems too madly in love; and probably Casey is not paying her the attention she is looking for (thats a woman reaction thing). She is not that great of a singer to my knowledge to be criticizing another artist to that level in public television. Dear Miss last Coca Cola,.. as a viewer, you must APOLOGIZE to him and to the American public.

o0ber Says:

Mar 4, 2010 - He sounded great in the first part but starting with the chorus I didn't like it. To be fair I've never really loved any of the covers of this song on this show... Something about the song makes it hard to sing for most people. In Casey's case I don't think his voice has enough power.

39willieparker Says:

Mar 4, 2010 - Kara looked like a fool with her panties in a bunch, panties in a bunch. She was looking like a fool with her panties in a bunch.

snoozy81 Says:

Mar 4, 2010 - He certainly has great talent and style, but agree that it is more about singing than instrument playing and last performances stood out a LOT more.

Mr82439 Says:

Mar 5, 2010 - he got cocky

felicita29 Says:

Mar 5, 2010 - wrong song....next time Bryan Adams....run to you/ cuts like a knife.....or Keith Urban.....but he is still cute :)

swtpee32 Says:

Mar 5, 2010 - their clowing him. lol didnt have the grit

thecougar2 Says:

Mar 5, 2010 - She clowned him because she got trapped with the"memo" that we all know. Cara dear , that is not the way to treat a baby!... and you are not the greatest singer. Your have a big mouth and you are not the last Coca Cola. The word "Dirt" only comes from Dirty people. ..get the hint?

tammiele2 Says:

Mar 6, 2010 - i definitely love Casey's voice <3

KeiraLe Says:

Mar 7, 2010 - I understand not having grit. Sand, that too i can understand. But dirt? not cool.

DORIOR Says:

Mar 7, 2010 - The guy really know how to play.Ellen DeGeneres understands about music as I understand about dancing, and i don't. What's her connection to music?

Arshavin231292 Says:

Mar 7, 2010 - i still liked him singing heaven as he showed all his feelings...maybe for kara

asportsfanx Says:

Mar 7, 2010 - The dirt thing was really uncalled for...Casey was very good on vocals and great on his electric guitar last Wednesday.

riexan12 Says:

Mar 10, 2010 - so cool.. i love this guitar..

jcarrillo30 Says:

Mar 13, 2010 - they r right the guitar was great but the voice was covered by all the music and wasnt that great but still the dirt comment was rude

amazon1206 Says:

Mar 16, 2010 - i really dont understand kara what shes trying to say here, im confused!

amazon1206 Says:

Mar 16, 2010 - casey really cool...hes cool taking the opinion of the judges! love his attitude!

moso208 Says:

Mar 30, 2010 - I thought you were awesome, Casey!! It wasn't my most favorite song you have sang but it was definately the most interesting to watch! Love your guitar playing!! It's obvious Kara was just trying to cover for being all googley over you the previous week, which it totally unfair to you because you can't help that you're hot!!! Kara needs to learn to be more professional!

thefunnyparody123 Says:

May 4, 2010 - he can play like fu*king crazy and sing good as sh*t

kshanet Says:

Jun 10, 2010 - I love Casey's voice here. Just don't know what's Simon and Kara's problem. They hated rock star image of Casey but Casey still stood out as rock star on the finale night  with Bret Michaels.

mvalliere5 Says:

Aug 7, 2010 - WHATS IN THE BOX!