Thelma Aoyama feat. 4minute - WITHOUT U [English Version]

zwweet Says:

Sep 26, 2011 - Agree with you :)

thepeaceist Says:

Sep 26, 2011 - And now you wanna say all kpop idols cant sing live ? GTH troll ! 4minute is much better than that ugly singer .You better check out gayoon solo perfromance in japan,jiyoon on immortal song ,their voice and vocal is much btter than aoyama ,so do talk with fact yeahh ;)

thepeaceist Says:

Sep 26, 2011 - This song is just nothing without 4minute .

KyoyaOotory1GF Says:

Sep 28, 2011 - Hyuna doesnt sing too much in this song just like 1 line

rennazhang426 Says:

Oct 3, 2011 - Aoyama rocks!!!

TrueKingDark Says:

Oct 5, 2011 - dude 4 minute is better i would'nt look at this without them

RicoDaDude Says:

Oct 12, 2011 - Never heard of Thelma Aoyama before this song, but I love it :D. Gayoon's english is really good.

FiqriAmirul Says:

Nov 3, 2011 - 4minitues <------ ??? wkaKWKAKWKAK

FiqriAmirul Says:

Nov 4, 2011 - jiyoon ,, wow ,,,

TheHeavenlyheaven Says:

Nov 9, 2011 - thelma's been my fav since her duet with soulja ^^her voice is perfect..her english also ^^

lilBEAT212 Says:

Nov 13, 2011 - <3 i luff 4minute and thelma aoyama is an amazing singer!dreamed of this day coming~

AznFlex1 Says:

Dec 1, 2011 - " I been threw da rain and I been threw hare n back! ""...Cuz I had to tak it slow "Lol...

iamnumber3six Says:

Dec 3, 2011 - this song sounds like ' i like you the best b2st ''

M0NKiiEEPOOPxD Says:

Dec 3, 2011 - lol guess what? Thelma is more well known than 4Minute.

TrueKingDark Says:

Dec 13, 2011 - i don't care

nana0hanm Says:

Dec 23, 2011 - 4MINUTE :) <3

olbywong717c Says:

Jan 18, 2012 - This is one very "massive" video. =p

xTheLittleStrawberry Says:

Feb 29, 2012 - Thelma <3

xTheLittleStrawberry Says:

Feb 29, 2012 - Quit being a troll. Thelma Aoyama has amazing talent. She has a deep soulful voice. You can't compare Gayoon or Jiyoon's voice to Thelma's because they have different styles of singing. 4minute is a pop group while Thelma is more of an R&B singer. Plus determining who has a better voice is simply an opinion. There is no "fact"..

zwweet Says:

Mar 11, 2012 - Very nice and hidden tactic to bash 4minute! :)If Thelma didn´t think 4minute had enough skills, why would she even collab with them? She respects them, so I think you as her fan should do the same ^^They´re both amazing and talented artists, no need for bringing one of them down ^^ Though, a solo version with Thelma Aoyama would be cool ^o^ :D

zwweet Says:

Mar 11, 2012 - Yeah, the melody is kind of... exactly the same xD But I love how they still made it sound so completely different and turn it into such a calm and pretty song! ;D I wish they´d do that with all B2ST song! 8D (y) (y)

gepee Says:

Apr 14, 2012 - Yes, i like it. So i dont like to compare them cause they both have a good voice and i like all of them

HtweYi Says:

May 7, 2012 - So not true. Aoyama can totally pull this song off by herself. Her voice is amazing compare to one of the girls from 4 minutes who comes in at 1:57 ...Aoyama has a cool and glossy voice unlike the other girl, whose voice sounds like she has a cold with stuffy nose.

zwweet Says:

May 16, 2012 - I´VE HAD IT.This a frikkin COLLAB between the artists, we should join together loving the song!So why can´t we? Why must we insist Thelma/4minute is better? :sThey´re both amazing, chill, listen to the song, AND STOP FIGHTING! ^__^